Why Gluten-Free is just the Tip of the Iceberg

Thirty years ago, when I worked in a small health food store in Portland, Oregon, I was the go-to-guy for the gluten-free crowd. Whenever someone would walk into the store and want to know how they could avoid gluten, I would walk them around and show them the few items we had and give them advice on how to navigate our gluten-filled world.

Picture1

Today, things are completely different. A recent survey suggested that up to thirty percent of adults are now interested in kicking gluten out of their diets. Most restaurants now have gluten-free options on the menu, and some have completely separate menus.

Whether you are new to gluten-free or are just learning about it now, there is a question most people have never thought to ask: why is gluten a problem for you to eat?

The simple answer to that question is that gluten is a problem for humans because our bodies are not able to handle this protein. But what does that mean about other proteins and other foods that we eat every day?

Understanding why gluten is a problem and why the problem has gotten worse in the last decade leads you down the rabbit hole of dietary nutrition to a place where you might end up questioning everything you learned about nutrition and everyone who puts their hand on our food (from food scientists, to farmer, to manufacturer).

To understand how gluten came to be such a problem and how it affects our health, we need to follow our food from the food scientists who manipulate it, into our digestive tracts, and into our blood streams. What you are going to discover is that, while gluten can be a problem, it is not alone. The problems gluten and its friends can cause are enormous and have wide-reaching consequences for your health today and into tomorrow.

First Stop: Food Scientists

A group of people has been changing our plants for generations. While some of these people have been farmers and others have worked in laboratories, they have all made changes to our foods; I’ll call them add the food scientists.

While there is a current uproar about GMO (genetically modified organisms), food scientists have been changing the structure of our grains and other foods for decades. For example, the wild wheat plant (the distant cousin of the wheat we eat today) had only 14 chromosomes, while the modern wheat has 42. Most of the changes to the genetic makeup of wheat happened well before the advent of modern genetic modification.

What do those additional chromosomes in our wheat do? The scientists enthusiastically modified our grains to better handle drought, withstand machinery, or have longer shelf life; they synthetically altered our plants to resist (or produce their own) pesticide. While all of these sound like good things, there is one thing missing from the equation: are these changes better for humans?

One thought drove the modifications of our seeds and plants: make the best plant for the farmer/producer/manufacturer. While I’m happy to make a plant grow better for our farmers and have it last longer on our shelves, I’m astonished that they didn’t remember humans would eventually consume that food.

All of these manipulations were made without the consideration that these foods would eventually end up in human mouths and human digestive tracts. Has anyone wondered what happens when a human eats a food that now has additional chromosomes, more proteins, and contains pesticides?

Immune System

Our digestive systems are the center of our immune system. This notion might seem strange until you realize that our largest contact with the outside world (beyond our skin) is our digestive system. Our digestive system, unlike our skin, is selectively deciding whether molecules from the outside world (the food we eat) are going to be allowed inside our bodies. This means that your digestive system needs to be on guard for anything that may do us harm. It is for this reason that 80 percent of our immune system is surrounding our digestive tract.

Why should you care that your immune system is a large part of your digestive system? The immune system can be very sensitive to molecules it considers harmful. In a sort of perfect storm for many digestive tracts, the molecules most likely to enrage the immune system are proteins (remember that proteins are exactly what food scientists have been increasing in grains for years).

A lot of the ills of modern society can be traced back to inflammation and the immune system controls inflammation in the body. When our bodies are exposed to the wrong proteins in an intimate way (like foods in our digestive tract), inflammation is the result.

Proteins in Plants

While other foods we eat (fats, carbohydrates) can increase inflammation and engage the immune system, proteins get a gold star for the ability to irritate our digestive tract, trigger an immune response, and increase inflammation.

Most people have heard of gluten and the problems it can cause. Glutens are proteins that naturally found in grains that are what makes wheat such an amazing grain. Glutens hold and bind the grain together making it possible for bread to rise and cookies to hold together. The wild version of wheat certainly does contain gluten, but the amount of gluten in wheat has skyrocketed in the last 100 years.

The immune systems of many people are reactive to gluten. People with severe reactions to gluten experience diarrhea, bloating, and pain whenever they eat even a small amount of gluten. Some people are so reactive that even gluten touching their skin will cause a reaction. The inflammation caused by gluten is so bad in people with celiac disease that their digestive tracts cannot absorb nutrients properly and they begin to show signs of deficiency diseases.

But gluten is far from being the only protein on the block; there are other proteins that cause your digestive and immune system problems.

To understand these other proteins, you need to first understand something about plants: they don’t want to be eaten. Unlike animals, plants cannot protect themselves by running away, or by using teeth, claws, or horns. To keep from being eaten, plants have developed protective proteins (like gluten and others) that help deter animals from eating them.

Plants can also use proteins to aid in their reproduction. A good strategy if you are a seed is to be eaten by an animal, but not digested (if the seed moves through the animal who has eaten it quickly it can start growing somewhere else). Lectins are the proteins that accomplish this job, they irritate the digestive tract enough so that the animal eating it won’t digest it and the seed will move the digestive tract unharmed.

Lectins

Lectins play a duel role; they act as natural plant pesticides when the plant is alive and they irritate the digestive tract and create inflammation of any animal unlucky enough to eat them. Research has shown just how good lectins are at irritating digestive tracts as they bind to the lining of the gut setting off a chain reaction of inflammation throughout the body.[i] Lectins are resistant to digestion and can be absorbed into the bloodstream where they continue to engage the immune system, where some researchers have suggested they play a role in autoimmune diseases[ii] such as rheumatoid arthritis, lupus and even diseases such as multiple sclerosis.[iii]

The problem with lectins is that they are not just found in grains, lectins are also found in eggs, nightshade plants (tomato, potato, eggplant, peppers), beans (soy, pinto, kidney…), peanuts, nuts, grains (wheat, rye, barley, malt, oats…), dairy foods, almost all processed foods. If you have digestive problems, you may want to consider avoiding all foods that are high in lectins for a while and see how you feel.

The research on lectins is just beginning and I think the future will show that everyone has certain lectins that they will have problems with and that not all lectins are bad. Stay tuned…

Pesticides

One of the mind-blowing aspects of grain production is that some grains have been genetically modified to produce their own pesticides. All of this without any thought about what happens when we eat those foods. Essentially no research has been done on this topic, but you would be well served to avoid genetically modified foods.

The potential for our digestive and immune systems to react to the increased glutens, lectins, added chromosomes, and pesticides grows with each manipulation by our food scientists. All of these alterations of our grains have changed them from a second-rate food choice to one that is toxic and harmful.

 

[i] Freed DL. Do dietary lectins cause disease? BMJ. 1999 Apr 17;318(7190):1023-4. PMID: 10205084.

[ii] Freed DL. Do dietary lectins cause disease? BMJ. 1999 Apr 17;318(7190):1023-4. PMID: 10205084.

[iii] Mendez-Huergo SP, Maller SM, et al. Integration of lectin-glycan recognition systems and immune cell networks in CNS inflammation. Cytokine Growth Factor Rev. 2014 Mar 12. PMID: 24684768.

< Previous Article
What is Wrong With Wheat?
Next Article >
About the Author

I'm Dr. Scott Olson ND. I'm a Naturopathic doctor who specializes in diet, health, nutrition, and alternative medicine. I've written numerous books and articles on health, medicine, and alternative medicine I want to help you get healthy! Take a look at my blog and make sure you join in the conversation!

11 Comments on this article. Feel free to join this conversation.

  1. Sue August 25, 2015 at 12:40 am - Reply

    Listening to our body is so important. It tells us things – and we often ignore the subtler messages, until we get a big flare-up and we pay attention at last. Since giving up gluten and dairy and refined sugar (including alcohol here) – also caffeine – I feel great and enjoy food more because I know I won’t get a horrid reaction. I am more adventurous in my cooking – lots of fresh food now – no more junk. The way to go!_

    • Dr. Scott August 25, 2015 at 6:12 am - Reply

      Sue, I agree. Thanks for your wonderful comments.

      Dr. Scott

  2. Heather May 30, 2015 at 9:07 pm - Reply

    Dr. Scott

    I was just diagnosed on may 14, 2015 as having MS. What shocks me most in this is the connection I just read in your arrival, where do we go and what do we eat so we do not end up killing our kids?
    I never though eating grains, fruits, veggies, would cause such a major health problem.

    Heather

    • Dr. Scott May 31, 2015 at 11:47 am - Reply

      Hi Heather, I love the program by Dr. Terry Wahls for MS. It is amazing how our food has changed and how much it can harm us.

      Best of luck,

      Dr. Scott

  3. PJ July 5, 2014 at 11:01 pm - Reply

    Dear Dr. Scott,

    I have consulted four (3) allergy doctors and a naturopathic doctor. I have had back pricks, arm pricks, hair analysis, and patch tests on my back. I also had a gluten test via blood samples. I am a middle-age female and suddenly developed food allergies approx. 2 1/2 years ago and no one can tell me exactly why. Neither of the two prick tests are conclusive. They didn’t reveal any food allergies; however, the patch tests did show reactions to cobalt, chromium and neomycin. With both the cobalt and chromium food items to avoid, they ironically match the hair analysis that was performed as well. Needless to say, all four tests were completed by different doctors. I was provided with a list of items to avoid, but the list seems to increase with trial and error. I don’t really know if I should avoid the food item until I’ve consumed it and suddenly eczema, blisters and swelling appears on my face, arms, hands, neck and upper chest/shoulders. I have lost approx. 15 lbs over a period of 2 1/2 years and it is very, very challenging when you can’t figure out what else to eat.

    I was provided a safe list of products from the last allergist I saw; however, not all of the items are safe for me to use. I have to use the” trial and error” method. I learned through a web blog which contact solution to use because I react to corn products. I can not find a moisturizer for my face that I don’t react to…even the most mild from shea butter to baby lotions/creams, so I just use Vaseline. Even with this, I have learned that not all vaselines are the same.

    I don’t know if this was brought on by stress, hormones or what. We had some work done in our home around the time when this all started, which made me think of Chinese dry wall. Dry wall is one the materials listed as an allergen to the Cobalt and/or chromium, but my husband swears we don’t have any Chinese dry wall in our home. If that were the case, he and my child would have the same problem.

    I have resorted to two things, contacting the Doctors (you), Dr. Oz or the Mayo Clinic. I am very frustrated and want to live a normal life again. I have done a lot of research on my own, but I am hitting a brick wall.

    Please help!

    • Dr. Scott July 6, 2014 at 4:46 pm - Reply

      PJ, I’m sorry to hear about your problems. Many people people run into this problem with no previous symptoms; something starts the problem and it can be hard to identify.

      I wish there were a better method than the “trail and error” but it is actually the best. Many of the tests you have taken are testing the wrong part of the immune system. Tests done to the skin are testing what are called “IgE” which the ones in your digestive tract are “IgA”. Even when you have a blood test for IgA, you might be missing local digestive intolerance. As you well know, it can be complicated, but the only way to weed out the foods that don’t work for you. Avoiding all grains is a great place to start (if you haven’t already done that) and then move on to the more common food allergies.

      The best method I know is to avoid all common allergens; take a look at this article on food allergies: I’m allergic to Everything! As you can tell from the comments, you are not alone.

      Best wishes,

      Dr. Scott

      • PJ July 7, 2014 at 9:35 pm - Reply

        Thanks, Dr. Scott. I really enjoyed the article. It seems that I have done everything it suggests; however, I will look more into the lectins. There seems to be a correlation between the foods that contain chromium and lectins itself. I will also look into finding someone who can check my immune system as well.

        I appreciate your quick response!

  4. Bren June 16, 2014 at 4:38 pm - Reply

    I have multiple food allergies too. I am very reactive to corn. I was instructed by my Dr to not eat chicken because of it being corn fed, or beef or pork if I know it was corn fed. Just wanted to add this to your comment about meats being safe to eat if you react to lectins. Just know your source

    • Dr. Scott June 17, 2014 at 8:05 am - Reply

      Bren, that is such a good point! Eggs and meat fed with corn can cause reactions in people who are sensitive to lectins. Yes, know how the animals you eat are fed!

      Dr. Scott

  5. Sandy Koutalis June 10, 2014 at 7:09 pm - Reply

    Is there ANY food that is safe? From reading the article the answer is a resounding NO! What can we eat? I have been on a Gluten Free diet for a couple of years & recently changed to a Paleo diet but is it safe?
    Concerned Foodáholic
    Sandy Koutalis

    • Dr. Scott June 11, 2014 at 8:24 am - Reply

      Hi Sandy,

      It is easy to feel that no food is safe, but there are plenty of foods that are safe – they just aren’t as tasty as the ones the harm us. Paleo is a good way to go as all meat proteins appear to be safe and most plants (excluding grains) are safe as well.

      Dr. Scott

Leave A Response